Building capacity to help Africa trade better

Repurposing the World Bank and the MDBs to meet 21st century challenges


Repurposing the World Bank and the MDBs to meet 21st century challenges

Repurposing the World Bank and the MDBs to meet 21st century challenges
Photo credit: Reuters | Stringer

Finance and development ministers gathered in Washington this weekend at the World Bank’s annual meetings had an ambitious agenda of topics to discuss. But the truth is, it is not nearly ambitious enough. A new CGD report by a high level commission of development and finance experts explains why and what should happen.

The report, titled Multilateral Development Banking for This Century’s Development Challenges, urges ministers to rethink priorities of the World Bank in the light of changes in the multilateral system, that now includes more than six other large and politically significant regional banks. The banks as a group need to be better equipped to tackle urgent transnational problems of our time – for example, the risk of antibiotic resistance and forced migration.

Shareholders ought to think of these banks not as individual institutions competing for scarce resources, but as a system of complementary actors. They should build on the key role of the World Bank as the only truly global bank in addressing transnational problems, while looking to the full potential of the regional banks to address their borrowing members’ growing investment needs, particularly but not only in infrastructure.

“A unique moment for the MDBs to embrace ambition”

The year-long assessment of the MDBs by CGD’s High Level Panel on the Future of Multilateral Development Banking, co-chaired by Montek Ahluwalia, Lawrence Summers, and Andres Velasco, lays out a vision for the shareholders of the World Bank and major regional MDBs for the next decade, taking into account the ambitious commitments made by the world’s leaders in 2015: the Paris climate accord and the Sustainable Development Goals. It argues that the MDBs can certainly be part of the solution to today’s global challenges.

“We see a unique moment for the MDBs to embrace ambition,” the report says. “We strongly believe that the MDB model – combining technical and financial capacity in a politically-backed cooperative – remains the best available vehicle for tackling the critical new challenges facing the global community.”

The report recognizes the fundamental importance of addressing climate change to further progress on development, and the catastrophe that will unfold in the absence of truly global-level collective action in financing and deploying climate-friendly programs in the developing world. To this end, the Panel recommends a new mandate for the World Bank to focus on global public goods, enabled with $10 billion in new grant resources to research and deployment of new energy and health technologies, to foster the nascent “green” bonds market, and to issue loans and guarantees on terms that encourage borrowers to take on the upfront costs of climate mitigation. This would be as a complement to the traditional lending operations of the bank.

Sustainability should be at the heart of what the World Bank does. So, the panel further proposes that the name of the IBRD (the World Bank’s main mechanism for lending to middle-income countries) be changed to IBRSD, the International Bank for Reconstruction and Sustainable Development.

Time for the World Bank to set the trend again

Over many decades the World Bank has set the trend, for example, taking leadership on lending to poor countries in the 1960s. Now the panel is calling on it to take leadership on raising grant money, setting priorities for collective action and deploying resources when appropriate to other institutions to address global public goods.

This proposed shift for the World Bank also highlights the need for clearer differentiation between its own role in infrastructure and that of the regional development banks. The World Bank’s role should be to do only what is truly “green.” The report suggests the regional banks take the lead in increasing MDB-supported infrastructure investment from $50 billion to $200 billion a year, with a view to crowding in much more in private capital, as well as sustaining traditional country operations in education, agriculture and other sectors.

The panel offers recommendations in five areas: global public goods, sustainable infrastructure, the role of “concessional” financing, crisis management, and a shareholder-led governance agenda. In each of these areas, CGD’s high level panel recognizes the tremendous potential of the MDBs, as well as the risks and missed opportunities associated with a business-as-usual approach.

We very much hope that the high level panel’s report will spur fresh thinking among the banks’ shareholders about the future roles and mandates of the different MDBs. Ultimately, it is the ministers gathered this weekend in Washington, and in future meetings, who have the power to set a strategic path for the MDB system as a whole. Today’s global challenges demand that they take up the charge.

Regional Development Bank heads respond to CGD’s Panel on Multilateral Development Banking

We, the Heads of the Regional Development Banks (RDBs), welcome the report of the Center for Global Development’s High-Level Panel on Multilateral Development Banking. This is an important report at a critical moment, as we move into high gear to deliver on the ambition of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development and the historic Paris agreement on climate. As the Panel recognizes, the Multilateral Development Banks (MDBs) are essential and uniquely-qualified players in the international financial architecture.

In particular, we applaud the approach taken by the Panel to view the MDBs as a system; we believe that only by embracing a system-wide approach can shareholders ensure that the full potential of the MDBs is exploited. In this regard, we welcome the Panel’s suggestion for periodic system-wide reviews by shareholders to look at governance structures, capacities and needs, including capital, across institutions and regions, with a view to setting a comprehensive and coherent strategic agenda.

We take note of the Panel’s recommendations that aim to strengthen the collective MDB response to delivering global public goods. We welcome the report’s findings that the RDBs should take an increasing role in operations supporting global and regional public goods, and that RDBs – because of their regional focus – are better placed to meet financing needs for climate-smart and resilient infrastructure. We are pleased that the report also recognizes our role as a trusted partner to our client countries, which has also allowed us to support key policy and institutional reforms in a variety of areas, including education and health, as well as our role in crowding in private investment.

At the same time, we believe that any discussions of focal areas across institutions should be based on a granular assessment of areas of specialist expertise and operational capacity. Notably, the RDBs have proven track records of innovation and they have each developed areas of world-class expertise which could be leveraged more effectively across the system. Our four institutions have begun to examine how to deploy our particular strengths and further enhance our individual and collective efforts to deliver the greatest impact in our respective countries of operation.

In the coming months and years, we have only a short window of opportunity to put in place the enhancements to the MDB system which would allow us to maximize our collective impact in supporting the delivery of the 2030 Agenda. Let us work together to ensure that the system of MDBs as a whole will deliver to its maximum potential.

Akinwumi ADESINA, President of the African Development Bank

Takehiko NAKAO, President of the Asian Development Bank

Suma CHAKRABARTI, President of the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development

Luis Alberto MORENO, President of the Inter-American Bank Group



    Email This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.
    Tel +27 21 880 2010